Is everything really moving towards AppChains?

8/28/2024, 2:00:16 PM
Intermediate
BlockchainDeFi
The article analyzes the trend of dApps shifting towards AppChains and the economic and strategic considerations behind this move. It explores the business model challenges faced by dApps, the limitations of their revenue sources, and their role in value creation and distribution within the broader transaction supply chain. The article presents three solutions: becoming an AppChain, selecting an L1/L2 to return value, and implementing application-specific ordering mechanisms. It discusses the cost-effectiveness and potential value of each solution and delves into the concepts of chain abstraction and application-specific ordering, highlighting how these ideas can offer new value capture opportunities for dApps.

Well yes, but actually no.

The main reason why dApps move to sovereign chains is because they believe they are being robbed.

And it’s not far from the truth, as the majority of dApps are not profitable.

You can consider the recent example of @zkxprotocol shutting down, and many other apps in the past like @utopialabs_, @yield, @FujiFinance, and more.

But is the business model truly that flawed, or are protocols actually being robbed?

The primary source (and often the only one) of income for a dApp is fees. Fees are paid by users because they directly benefit from them.

However, users are not the only parties that benefit from dApp usage.

There are several actors who profit from the transaction supply chain, but primarily they are block proposers, even though they are the last to see the transactions. In the case of L2s, these are sequencers.

MEV is heavily extracted, which is not always a bad thing, but the value that dApps create is taken away from them, so they do not receive the full value they provide.

There are currently 3 ways to address this:

  1. Become an appchain.

  2. Select an L1/L2 that returns value.

  3. Implement app-specific sequencing.

Like everything in crypto each solution comes with its tradeoffs.

  1. Becoming an appchain: High Cost + High Value

There are countless pros you get: extract value as much as you want, control your own network (if you’re L2), scale easier, avoid competing for blockspace, and more.

Cons: it’s really expensive, like really expensive. And it’s harder to do, because you have to craft both app and chain.

Even if you want to build an L2 and use solutions like @alt_layer.

Thesis that every app will eventually become an appchain is generally broken, because of 3 reasons:

  • Not every dapp is big enough to have a need to move to an appchain.

  • Some dapps directly benefit from architecture of underlying chain.

  • Dapps feel pretty comfortable on another chain.

  1. L1/L2 that returns value: Low Cost + Mid Value

Deploying app on a rollup or L1 costs way less, because you don’t have to implement new rules for validation, inclusion, consensus, transaction flow, etc.

In case of rollups: it’s really easy (most of the times) to bring your app from Ethereum to a rollup, because the rollup is either EVM-compatible (e.g. @arbitrum), or EVM-equivalent (e.g. @taikoxyz).

You still have to consider the architecture of underlying chain, but you don’t have to build it from scratch.

Maybe in the future we will have TRUE chain abstraction, where devs don’t have to care about anything but their dapp, but that is another story…

Devs get mid value in return because it’s not high (you don’t own chain economy), but not low as well (you get some value in return apart from fees).

Currently there are hardly any implementations of it, as sharing MEV with dapps is still a complex process, we need to do more R&D.

  1. App-specific sequencing: Mid Cost + Uncertain Value

The concept of app-specific sequencing is quite new and people often mix it up with appchain, the difference is simple:

  • Appchain cares about sequencing and execution.

  • Self-sequenced dapp cares about sequencing only, “outsourcing” execution to L1/L2

It’s mid cost, because you have to think about ordering transactions apart from dapp building, and the value is uncertain, because the concept is quite new and has different concerns.

First of all, you still depend on proposer, because of games of inclusion: you can send any bundle you want to send, but the decision to include your bundle or not lies on the shoulders of a proposer.

There is no clear incentive for a proposer to include your bundle in the block, if you will take all MEV.

So it opens another market of incentives for proposers. They (dapp + proposer) should collaborate, otherwise none of them have any value or power.

It also has uncertain value because we don’t know for sure if shared value from L1/L2 will exceed the value the dapps will create for themselves via ordering transactions.


Any chain is a dark forest (not only Ethereum!). So back to the question at the beginning:

Is everything really moving towards AppChains?

  1. Well, yes (there are some dapps that benefit from having their own chain more than staying on existing one).

  2. Well, no (there are other solutions suitable for dapp needs)

The forest is pretty big for exploring all of the options.

Every landscape in the world (crypto) has some diversity, so choose what better suits your needs or build your own solution!

statement:

  1. This article is reproduced from [@paramonoww], the copyright belongs to the original author [@paramonoww ], if you have any objections to the reprint, please contact the Gate Learn team, and the team will handle it as soon as possible according to relevant procedures.

  2. Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article represent only the author’s personal views and do not constitute any investment advice.

  3. Other language versions of the article are translated by the Gate Learn team and are not mentioned in Gate.io, the translated article may not be reproduced, distributed or plagiarized.

Share

Content

Crypto Calendar

Proje Güncellemeleri
Etherex, 6 Ağustos'ta REX token'ını piyasaya sürecek.
REX
22.27%
2025-08-06
NFT AI Ürün Lansmanı
Nuls, üçüncü çeyrekte bir NFT AI ürünü piyasaya sürecek.
NULS
2.77%
2025-08-06
dValueChain v.1.0 Lansmanı
Bio Protocol, ilk çeyrekte dValueChain v.1.0'ı piyasaya sürmeye hazırlanıyor. Amacı, DeSci ekosisteminde güvenli, şeffaf ve değiştirilemez tıbbi kayıtlar sağlamak için merkeziyetsiz bir sağlık veri ağı kurmaktır.
BIO
-2.47%
2025-08-06
Yapay Zeka Tarafından Üretilen Video Altyazıları
Verasity, dördüncü çeyrekte AI tarafından üretilen video altyazı fonksiyonu ekleyecek.
VRA
-1.44%
2025-08-06
VeraPlayer Çok Dilli Destek
Verasity, dördüncü çeyrekte VeraPlayer'a çok dilli destek ekleyecek.
VRA
-1.44%
2025-08-06

Related Articles

In-depth Explanation of Yala: Building a Modular DeFi Yield Aggregator with $YU Stablecoin as a Medium
Beginner

In-depth Explanation of Yala: Building a Modular DeFi Yield Aggregator with $YU Stablecoin as a Medium

Yala inherits the security and decentralization of Bitcoin while using a modular protocol framework with the $YU stablecoin as a medium of exchange and store of value. It seamlessly connects Bitcoin with major ecosystems, allowing Bitcoin holders to earn yield from various DeFi protocols.
11/29/2024, 10:10:11 AM
Solana Need L2s And Appchains?
Advanced

Solana Need L2s And Appchains?

Solana faces both opportunities and challenges in its development. Recently, severe network congestion has led to a high transaction failure rate and increased fees. Consequently, some have suggested using Layer 2 and appchain technologies to address this issue. This article explores the feasibility of this strategy.
6/24/2024, 1:39:17 AM
The Future of Cross-Chain Bridges: Full-Chain Interoperability Becomes Inevitable, Liquidity Bridges Will Decline
Beginner

The Future of Cross-Chain Bridges: Full-Chain Interoperability Becomes Inevitable, Liquidity Bridges Will Decline

This article explores the development trends, applications, and prospects of cross-chain bridges.
12/27/2023, 7:44:05 AM
Sui: How are users leveraging its speed, security, & scalability?
Intermediate

Sui: How are users leveraging its speed, security, & scalability?

Sui is a PoS L1 blockchain with a novel architecture whose object-centric model enables parallelization of transactions through verifier level scaling. In this research paper the unique features of the Sui blockchain will be introduced, the economic prospects of SUI tokens will be presented, and it will be explained how investors can learn about which dApps are driving the use of the chain through the Sui application campaign.
6/13/2024, 8:23:51 AM
Navigating the Zero Knowledge Landscape
Advanced

Navigating the Zero Knowledge Landscape

This article introduces the technical principles, framework, and applications of Zero-Knowledge (ZK) technology, covering aspects from privacy, identity (ID), decentralized exchanges (DEX), to oracles.
1/4/2024, 4:01:13 PM
What Is Ethereum 2.0? Understanding The Merge
Intermediate

What Is Ethereum 2.0? Understanding The Merge

A change in one of the top cryptocurrencies that might impact the whole ecosystem
1/18/2023, 2:25:24 PM
Start Now
Sign up and get a
$100
Voucher!